The Best Bucket Caddies (Review & Buying Guide) in 2020

Whether you’re a mechanic, an electrician, a carpenter or a gardener, a bucket caddy can make your life easier. A...

Best Choice
bucket boss bucket
Bucket Boss 10030 Bucketeer
Premium Pick
premium pick bucket
Readywares Waxed Canvas Tool Bucket Organizer
Best Value
The Best Bucket Caddies (Review & Buying Guide) in 2020
Custom Leathercraft 61 In & Out Bucket Pockets

Whether you’re a mechanic, an electrician, a carpenter or a gardener, a bucket caddy can make your life easier. A proper tool organizer will allow you to conveniently and logically store all your gear, devices and accessories and carry them with you  with just one hand. They also save time, and as a result, money– when you’re on a job site, the last thing you need is to waste time looking for the right tools. With a handy bucket tool bag,  you’ll have everything you need right where you need it.

The world of bucket caddies is huge, however, and it can be difficult to find the right tool storage solution specifically for your needs. To help with that, we’ve compiled a list of the best bucket caddies currently on the market. Take a look at our top choices well as our buying guide to find the right product bucket tool organizer today.

The Best Bucket Caddy

Durable, spacious, professional-looking and highly convenient, the Bucket Boss is undoubtedly one of the best bucket caddies out there. It easily installs over five-gallon buckets, and since it comes with various dividers and pockets, it can be used for a variety of projects.

Made of PVC (55%), PP (22%), POLY (20%) and FERRIC (3%), the Bucketeer is highly durable, guaranteed to last a long time. There are 30 assorted storage pockets as well as three interior loops that allow you to hang your most commonly used gear, including larger tools such as hammers, drills and pry bars. And if you need more space for even larger tools? Nothing to worry about as the Buckeeter is made to allow for maximum storage space right inside the bucket. As a bonus, the bottom of the Bucketeer sits right above the base of the bucket, keeping it off the mud and dirty floors.

Because it’s so conveniently constructed, this tool bucket is perfect for auto work, gardening, fishing and all kinds of DIY projects. It also helps it’s super-affordable, making it ideal for both professionals and DIYers.

Key Features
  • Made of POLY, PVC, PP, FERRIC
  • Fits most 5 gallon buckets
  • 30 assorted pockets + 3 interior loops
  • Plenty of interior space
Specification
  • Brand Bucket Boss
  • Model 10030
  • Weight 1.35 pounds
PROS

Durable and sturdy

Can be used for a variety of projects

Plenty of pockets hold various tools and accessories

Affordable

CONS

Some of the pockets could be a bit bigger

Constructed for professionals and people who carry around lots of tools, especially large, bulky ones, the Custom Leathercraft is an excellent choice for folks who need their gear neatly organized. This bucket organizer easily fits most standard 3-1/2 to 5-gallon buckets.

Made of rugged ballistic polyester, this bucket caddy is ideal if you’re looking for sturdiness and durability. With 36 outside pockets and 25 inside pockets, the organizer provides lots of space and fits a wide range of tools and accessories. The outside pockets are perfect for small tools such as screwdrivers, pliers and sockets, while the inside pouches hold larger and bulkier tools with no issues. There is also a convenient little covered pocket on the outside that allows you to securely store your phone or other valuable items. Speaking of convenient features, this bucket tool organizer also has a tape loop that allows you to grab a piece of tape without removing it, keeping it in its place and right where you need it the next time. There is also a drill holster with pressure release clip which helps keep your drill safely in one place.

Finally, to ensure years-long durability, the bucket organizer has an extra layer of fabric to reinforce the rim of the bucket pockets. Perfect for handymen who carry heavy tools with them!

Key Features
  • Made of ballistic polyester
  • Fits 3 1/2 to 5 gallon buckets
  • 36 outside pockets + 25 inside pockets
  • Drill holder with side release buckle security strap
  • Tape loop dispenser
Specification
  • Brand Custom Leathercraft
  • Model 4122
  • Weight 12.8 ounces
PROS

Highly durable and sturdy

Ideal for carrying large, heavy tools

Lots of convenient features

CONS

Outside pockets could be a bit bigger

Lots of pockets may not be ideal for everyone

If you’re looking for an ultra-durable, ultra-sturdy bucket caddy and you don’t mind paying a little more to get it, the Readywares bucket organizer is the organizer for you. Incredibly durable and highly convenient, this heavy-duty bucket caddy is made for the toughest of jobs.

Constructed using quality materials, sturdy 20-ounce waxed cotton canvas, this tool organizer provides excellent protection for your gear, tools and accessories. It’s designed to fit all the tools you may need on the job – pockets fit all kinds of devices and tools, including batteries, screwdrivers, sockets and hammers. Speaking of pockets, there are 60 of them in total, some small enough to safely hold nails and pencils, and some big enough to fit crowbars and long hammers. There are also inner bucket loops which allow you to conveniently arrange your larger tools. There is also a special drill pocket. This is a 5-gallon bucket tool organizer so you shouldn’t have any problems fitting it around standard buckets.

As a bonus, the product comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee, so if for some reason it doesn’t work out for you and your tools, you can send it back and get a refund.

Key Features
  • Made from 20oz waxed cotton canvas
  • Fits standard 5 gallon buckets
  • 60 pockets in total + inner loops
  • Drill pocket
Specification
  • Brand Readywares
  • Weight 3 pounds
PROS

Super durable and sturdy

Fantastic workmanship

Plenty of storage

Can be used for a variety of projects

CONS

The waxed canvas is stiff in the beginning, so fitting is a bit hard

Pricey

Whether you wash vehicles for a  living or like to clean your own car regularly, a bucket wash organizer can help you do the job easier and quicker. This wash organizer by Bucket Boss is a perfect choice as it has everything you need to keep your cleaning and detailing products and other accessories neatly stored and organized. Plus, it can be used for cleaning in general – apartments, garages, vehicles, you name it!

Made of durable material and water-resistant mesh pockets, this 5 gallon bucket organizer is ideal for all things cleaning and washing. The are three large pockets on each side of the bucket, which is six pouches in total, that easily fit various cleaning supplies. There is also a ring on the side of the bucket that can hold a cleaning rag. The best part? There are no inner pockets or dividers, so you can fill the bucket with soap and water while your cleaning tools and detailing products conveniently hang on the side – it’s a complete cleaning station!

Like most Bucket Boss products, this one too is durable and budget-friendly, which is always a welcome bonus.

Key Features
  • Wash organizer with water-resistant mesh pockets
  • Fits 5 gallon buckets
  • 6 large pockets
  • Towel/cleaning rag ring
Specification
  • Brand Bucket Boss
  • Model AB30060
  • Weight 14.4 ounces
PROS

Makes car washing and house cleaning quick and easy

Pockets are large enough to fit most cleaning products

Affordable

CONS

Could use a couple more pockets

If your garage or working space looks like it could use some organization, why not try proper tool box organizers? Husky Bucket Jockey makes garage tool organization quick and easy as it stores a multitude of tools and supplies in one convenient place.

Made of 600 denier spun water-resistant material, this heavy-duty bucket caddie is ideal for various projects, including auto work, gardening and even fishing. There are 30 pockets in total, some of which are small enough to safely hold nails and pencils and some large enough to hold cleaning products, hammers and hand rakes. Most of the pockets are located on the outer side of the bucket, but some pouches are on the inside – these are the larger pockets, able to hold bulkier tools. Like most bucket toolboxes, this one too easily fits standard 5-gallon buckets, so no need to throw away that old can that’s collecting dust in your garage – recycle it by turning it into a super-convenient toolbox.

For those wondering about the durability,  you’ll be pleased to know that this product comes with a 3-year limited warranty.

Key Features
  • Made of heavy-duty, water-resistant material
  • Fits standard 5 gallon buckets
  • 30 pockets in total
Specification
  • Brand Husky
  • Model 82045N12
  • Weight 1.33 pounds
PROS

Durable and sturdy

Can be used for a variety of projects

Plenty of pockets hold a multitude of tools

Affordable

CONS

Some of the pockets could be a bit deeper and bigger

Another budget-friendly but durable and spacey bucket caddy, the NoCry bucket organizer is a great way to neatly arrange and store all your tools, devices, gear and accessories in one place. Whether you’re a mechanic, a lineman, a plumber or a car wash employee, this tool organizer can help you work faster and smarter.

The caddy is crafted from 600 ballistic canvas and reinforced with a waterproof material on the back that helps protect your tools from water, rain and snow. In other words, this is a heavy-duty bucket tool bag that is made to last for years to come. There are 35 pockets of various sizes, from small ones designed to hold nails and screwdrivers to large ones big enough to hold bulky tools.  If you’re wondering where they’re located, 27 of them are on the outside of the bucket and eight of them are on the inside (these can hold larger tools). There are also five loops and one simplex style metal hook and strap for tape and other items. Of course, you’ll also have some extra space inside the bucket itself where you can store things that cannot fit inside the pouches.

The bucket tool organizer fits most 3-gallon and 5-gallon buckets and comes with a no-hassle guarantee, meaning if you don’t like or it doesn’t work for you, you can get it replaced or get your money back.

Key Features
  • Made of ballistic canvas and waterproof material
  • Fits 3 gallon and 5 gallon buckets
  • 35 pockets in total
  • 5 loops + 1 simplex style tape hook
Specification
  • Brand NoCry
  • Weight 1.06 pounds
PROS

Highly durable and sturdy

Lots of pockets hold various tools

Can be used for a variety of projects

Affordable

CONS

The inside pockets could be larger

Best Bucket Caddy Buying Guide & FAQ

Working with a bucket caddy makes any job easier. This handy tool organizer is incredibly convenient as it allows you to arrange your working equipment and accessories just the way you like it and just where you need them. In fact, working with a quality bucket caddy is pretty much like working with a personal helper (only much cheaper!). A proper bucket tool organizer can hold all the tools you need to quickly and successfully finish a job/project, including hammers, nails, screwdrivers, measuring tapes, hand rakes, weeding knives, glue guns, even drills and other larger tools. Whatever you need, the bucket caddy provides. That’s why they’re irreplaceable products for working men and women, whether they’re gardeners, electricians, auto workers, plumbers or DIYers.

But how to find the best bucket caddy for yourself and your needs? Considering that the market is oversaturated with various tool organizers, including bucket caddies, it can be hard to find the product that will best serve your needs. But that’s why we exist – to help you find the best possible tool organizing solution, we’ve prepared this comprehensive buying guide. Here we cover everything you need to know about bucket caddies, including what to consider when looking to purchase one. We also talk about the major benefits of using quality toolbox organizers. Without further ado, let’s jump straight into the interesting stuff!

bucket caddies

What to Consider When Buying a Bucket Organizer

To find the best bucket caddy for yourself, you first need to figure out what you need it for. Are you an electrician? Maybe an avid gardener or a fisherman? A passionate DIYer? The work you do determines the type of a bucket caddy you need. For example, if you’re a professional and need a toolbox organizer on your job site, you may need a sturdier and more durable bucket tool organizer than a person who just frequently works on small projects around the house. Similarly, if you love working on various different house projects, you may need a bucket caddy with more pockets and pouches than say, a plumber.

After you figure out what you need a bucket caddy for, it’s time to break things down a little bit further. When buying a bucket tool bag, consider the following features and whether or not as well as how much you need them in your line of work.

  • Material (Durability)

Some bucket caddies are super-durable, others not so much. As you may have guessed it, this mostly depends on the materials used in the construction of caddies. For instance, materials such as canvas and strong fibers are highly durable and sturdy, guaranteed to last a very long time. They’re ideal for professionals and people who need their bucket caddies every day with them on the job. The downside? They’re usually more expensive. On the other hand, materials like cotton or polyester are less durable, however, they’re more than good enough for most people who use bucket caddies, especially DIYers. The biggest plus of such caddies is that they’re affordable.

  • Number of Pockets

Without pockets, bucket caddies would just be… well, buckets. The number of pockets, as well as their size, are super-important factors to consider before making any purchases. While many pockets and pouches are generally a plus as they can hold various tools and trinkets, some people prefer fewer pockets and more space inside the bucket. This is totally relative though as it depends on the work you intend to do with the caddie, the number of tools you use, their size, and finally your own preferences. Generally speaking, if you use large and bulky tools, you probably don’t use a ton of them, meaning you’ll want to focus on bucket caddies with fewer but larger pockets. On the other hand, if you use lots of small devices, accessories and tools such as nails, screwdrivers, tapes, pencils and so on, many smaller pouches will be a better choice. In any case, what’s important is to get a bucket tool organizer that is just right for you, not the best on paper, so always remember to take into account your own needs and preferences.

  • Bucket Compatibility

Don’t forget about the bucket compatibility. Some caddies are specifically constructed to work with a certain size and shape of a bucket and it’s important to keep that mind when looking at caddies. For instance, most caddies are built to work with 5-gallon round buckets, although some can also fit 3 gallon buckets. There are also caddies constructed for square containers but they’re much rarer than round bucket caddies.

Although you can always buy a new bucket to work with the caddie you like, it’s wiser to recycle what you already have. It’s better for the environment and your wallet.

  • Color and Style

Finally, color and style will also factor into your purchasing decision. Sure, the way a bucket caddie looks may not actually matter that much, but if you’re going to buy a brand new caddie, it’s a good idea to buy a good-looking one. Now, what makes for a good-looking bucket tool organizer differs from person to person, but generally speaking, it’s best to choose something that blends in with your uniform/work environment. For example, a garden tool organizer looks the best when in green and/or brown colors. However, if you plan to use a bucket caddy at a construction site, something that stands out is a much better idea (black and bright red, for example).

auto boss

Why You Should Buy a Bucket Tool Bag

Do you work with lots of tools but find tool belts to be too uncomfortable? Is your garage in a complete chaos but you’re out of tool storage ideas? Not to worry – a quality bucket caddy can make your job easier and your life more organized. Still not convinced you need a proper bucket caddy in your life? Maybe the following benefits of using a bucket tool organizer will help push you in the right direction.

  • It saves time (and money)

If you work with various devices and tools, small and big, it’s important to find a way to make them easily accessible at all times. Tool belts are an option, but depending on the type of your work, they can seriously hamper your range of motions. A good bucket caddie, which can not only hold small, medium and large tools with no issues, but that you can also carry around with just one hand, is super-easy to work with. A bucket caddy also allows you to arrange your tools logically so that you always have exactly what you need right next to you. This saves time, and as a result, money.

  • It’s good for a variety of projects

Whether you’re a gardener, a plumber, an electrician, or someone who works around the house a lot, a good bucket tool organizer can help you finish the job faster and easier. A bucket caddy can hold a multitude of tools and accessories, including hammers, screwdrivers, drills, scissors, adhesives, measuring tapes, hand rakes, weeding knives, and many, many more things. In essence, whether you’re a professional or a DIYer, a bucket caddy can make help you improve your work with convenience and ease.

  • It keeps your space clean and organized

If you own a lot of tools and trinkets, but don’t like cleaning and organizing that much, chances are, your garage/working area is looking rather chaotic. While some folks don’t mind a bit of chaos, most people function much better in structured and organized environments. Case in point: say you have a project that you need to finish as soon as possible; do you think spending hours looking for the right tools would be constructive?  Thought so. A clean, logically organized space is crucial if you actually want to get things done.

Related Posts: Best Tool Belts, Magnetic Wristbands, Truck Tool Boxes and Tool Chests

tool bucket

Our Top Pick

While all the bucket tool organizers featured on our Top List are great products, the best bucket caddy reward goes to Bucket Boss 10030 Buckteer. Why? For one, this caddie is highly durable and sturdy, two, it has lots of small and large pockets plus interior loops, and three, it’s very affordable. Perfect for both professionals and amateurs, this bucket caddy  can be used for a variety of jobs and projects. All in all, a fantastic 5-gallon bucket tool organizer on a budget!

Sources:

  1. How to Organize Tools – howstuffworks
  2. How to Organize Your Tools and Workshop – wikiHow