LAST UPDATED: November 12, 2020

Best Mechanic Tool Set (Review & Buying Guide) in 2021

Best Choice Best Mechanic Tool Set (Review & Buying Guide) in 2021 Crescent CTK170CMP2 Mechanics Tool Set
Premium Pick Best Mechanic Tool Set (Review & Buying Guide) in 2021 WORKPRO 408-Piece Mechanics Tool Set
Best Value stanley mix set Stanley STMT73795 Mixed Tool Set

Working on your vehicle is significantly easier if you have the right set of tools at your disposal. The better the tools, the better the results. One problem is that they can be a little pricey, particularly if you’re at the initial stages of expanding your tool collection.

We’ve put together this guide to help you find the best mechanic tool set for the job. They vary in content and price, but they are all good options if you plan on repairing your vehicle on a regular basis. Check out this list of our top picks below.

The Best Mechanic Tool Sets

Crescent has been manufacturing tools for well over 100 years, and a company doesn’t get that kind of run without building a loyal fan base. It also doesn’t get that far without assessment and innovation, and this set of tools is a result of this process.

Notice the 2 at the end of the model number? This is an updated version of an older product, a sequel if you like. And just like The Godfather Part 2 and Die Hard 2, it has taken the original, kept the best bits, and added a little sprinkle of extra quality.

The main improvement is the storage case, which is tougher and longer lasting, while the tools are easier to get in and out of their respective spaces. Speaking of tools, this is a really comprehensive collection. Some boxes are only going to come with wrenches and spanners, but that’s not the case here. In addition to those core tools, you also have several different pliers, Allen keys, and a universal screwdriver tool.

With a wide selection of well-made tools in a good quality case for a mid-range price – it’all very impressive.

Key Features
  • Excellent Storage Box
  • Good Variety of Tools
  • SAE & Metric Tools
Specification
  • Brand Crescent
  • Model CTK170CMP2
  • Weight 20 lbs

This is a very large toolkit from well-respected manufacturer Craftsmen, packing no less than 450 individual items in a well-designed case. Despite the amount of items, however, it’s not the most comprehensive kit in the world, and there are no pliers of any sort.

What you do get is a collection of socket heads, bits and Allen keys of such range and diversity that this will likely be the only kit you need to buy for a long time – at least as far as those tools go.

One thing to note is that this is pretty heavy, weighing in at around 35 pounds. Luckily, the storage case has built-in trays that slide out, so you can easily store this on a workbench or shelving unit and just take out the tools as you need them. Or, if you’re action star The Rock, you can lug it around with you – the choice is yours.

Key Features
  • 450 Piece Kit
  • Huge Variety of Drill Bits & Socket Heads
  • Complete Allen Key Kit
  • Handy Storage Case with Drawers
Specification
  • Brand Craftsmen
  • Model
  • Weight aprox. 35 lbs

While Stanley is a widely recognized tool brand, most people would probably associate Stanley more with home improvement tools than with automotive toolkits. Yet here it makes a foray into the automotive world, and, to be fair, it looks pretty good.

The company  has taken the effort to build a very well-balanced collection of mechanics tools. There are 210 items in total, including the usual socket wrench and universal screwdriver sets. They are supplemented by, among other things, a useful 6-inch adjustable wrench, a pair of pliers, and a utility knife. A 16-foot tape measure is a nod to the company’s DIY roots and not something you usually see in a mechanic’s toolbox – but who knows, it could be useful!

Overall, it’s a decent collection of well-made tools in a thoughtfully put-together collection.

Key Features
  • Chrome Vanadium Forged Tools
  • Useful Storage Case
  • Excellent Tool Variety
  • Polished Chrome Finish for Corrosion Protection
Specification
  • Brand Stanley
  • Model STMT73795
  • Weight 20.3 lbs

This toolkit from WORKPRO features 408 pieces, which means you get more than twice as many tools as some other selections. As a bonus, it comes with a 322-piece home repair hand tool kit. If you need a particular tool, there’s a good chance you will find it in this set.

These mechanic’s tools are contained in a three-drawer heavy-duty metal box, while the hand tool kit comes in a soft carrying bag. They are made of strong and durable chrome vanadium for a longer lifespan. They also feature a chrome finish for rust protection. Nearly all the tools you need for automotive or household jobs are included in this package, such as allen keys, bits, pliers, a hammer, screwdrivers, wire strippers, sockets, etc.

The aluminum box provides convenient storage and organization, so you always know where a particular tool lies. The hand tool kit carrying bag makes transporting household tools an easy task. WORKPRO also provides a lifetime guarantee in case you encounter any issues with the product.

Key Features
  • Large Selection of Tools
  • Bonus Hand Tool Kit Included
  • Screwdrivers, Pliers & Hammers Included
  • Lifetime Guarantee
Specification
  • Brand WORKPRO
  • Model W009044A

You almost feel sorry for DeWALT having to follow up that beast of a kit – almost anything is going to struggle to look impressive afterwards. Luckily though this isn’t just anything, it is, in fact, a very impressive mechanic tool set.

DeWALT is of course extremely well regarded as a manufacturer of high-quality tools, and they have brought that reputation to bear here on this set of mechanic tools. It should be noted they have omitted the extras found in sets with a broader load out – there are no pliers or hammer to be found in here.

What we do have instead is a total of 205 items, the vast majority of them being a very comprehensive collection of ratchet socket heads of every conceivable size. They are all built with the kind of quality associated with DeWALT, including incorporating the trademarked DeWALT DirectTorque technology. This allows greater torque to be brought to bear via the wrench head, making fastening and loosening that bit easier.

Key Features
  • Excellent 72 Tooth Ratchet
  • Tough, Durable Storage Case
  • DeWALT Quality Tools
Specification
  • Brand DeWalt
  • Model DMWT81534
  • Weight 26.5 lbs

If you’re going to concentrate on one area then you need to make sure you’re getting everything right. Craftsmen have followed this mantra with this set of car tools, which again ignores the paraphernalia of sets with a wider appeal, and have instead focused on wrenches.

To ensure that they are providing the best wrenches they can, Craftsmen have bundled into this kit not one but three of them, each one with a different drive size — 1/4 inch, 3/8 inch, and 1/2 inch. To complement them, we have a total of 92 socket heads across a wide range of sizes, ensuring that you will find one to suit near enough any application. The kit even comes bundled with a pair of extension bars to ramp up the torque where needed.

A universal screwdriver and a set of Allen Keys round out the set, but it is really all about those wrenches in reality. With a relatively modest price tag for a 165 piece (most of which are high-quality wrench parts), you’ve got decent value here, too.

Key Features
  • 92 Sockets in 3x Drive Sizes
  • 3x Ratchet Drivers, 2x Extension Bars
  • Includes Universal Screwdriver Device with Attaching Bits
Specification
  • Brand Craftsmen
  • Model 38165
  • Weight 19.65 lbs

This is one of the simpler kits on our list today, a fact reflected in the sub 90-dollar price tag, making it one of the cheaper sets of tools on our list. What we essentially have here is a good quality set of ratchet wrenches.

Similar to the product we looked at above; the set comes with three ratchet handles of 1/4, 3/8, and 1/2 inch. These are joined by a good set of spanners and a universal screwdriver handle with the usual variety of bits. Construction is good quality, made of tough steel with a polished chrome finish to protect against corrosion.

It must be noted that whilst they are cheaper than the Craftsman tools we looked at above, it is missing some of the extras from that kit too – the extension bars are an obvious omission here. Still, given the relatively low price tag, it’s hard to be too critical on what is a solid set of tools that could find a home in most mechanics tool boxes.

Key Features
  • A Complete Wrench Kit
  • 3x Round Head, Quick Release Wrenches
  • High Quality Steel Construction
  • Polished Chrome Finish
Specification
  • Brand Stanley
  • Model STMT71654
  • Weight 10 lbs

Our next product is the second from Crescent and is a bit of a hybrid collection of mechanics tools. By that, we mean that at the heart of the product are three very well designed and built ratchets, with the usual collection of wrench head attachments.

In addition to that though we have a broader selection of tools that we have seen in the last couple of options. Those great ratchets are joined then by a pair of pliers, an adjustable spanner, and a couple of universal screwdrivers with lots of bits. 

We should also point out too that just as with the other Crescent product this is an update on an earlier product. With this set, Crescent has also upgraded the storage box, again making it tougher whilst ensuring the tools fit into all the gaps properly for easy removal and replacement. 

That wider tool selection, coupled with the relatively low price makes this a very attractive option for anyone looking for an entry-level set of good quality car tools. 

Key Features
  • 170 Piece Kit
  • Good Tool Assortment
  • 3x Ratchet Handles
  • Solid Storage Case
Specification
  • Brand Crescent
  • Model CTK170MPN
  • Weight 22 lbs

This is another set of excellent wrenches that could form the base of any well-put-together mechanic tool set. DeWALT has put a lot of effort into constructing a well thought out kit that has a number of useful features to appeal to mechanics everywhere.

One of the standout features is the slim head that has been incorporated into the ratchet design. As anyone who has spent time under the hood or stretched out underneath a jacked up car can testify, sometimes there really isn’t a lot of space to work in. Slim head ratchets are then a real advantage when it comes to working on your car, and it’s great to see them included here.

The ratchet head also includes a quick-release button, and the sockets themselves have hard stamped, easy to read markings to make changes on the fly fast and simple. The ratchet also boasts a 72-tooth count, which is going to give a very secure hold on the sockets allowing you to utilize a high degree of torque.

While this is one of the more expensive wrench sets on the list, its high-quality construction cannot be denied.

Key Features
  • Knurled Surface for Excellent Grip
  • 72 Tooth Ratchet for High Torque Application
  • Slim Head Ratchet Design
  • Durable Storage Case
Specification
  • Brand DeWALT
  • Model DWMT72165
  • Weight 41.6 lbs

Just look at the image of this Craftsman mechanic tool set with the sockets and ratchets all lined up — it looks like a treasure chest designed for mechanics. It’s also easy to see that what we have here is another dedicated ratchet set, although there are a few extras to enjoy too.

Let’s get right to the meat of this sandwich, however, and look at the ratchets and sockets. First up, these are Craftsman tools so you know you’re getting quality construction. These tools are made of very durable alloy steel and have been given a finish in silver for anti-corrosion protection.

The kit contains the usual 3x ratchet line up in the normal sizes, complemented by a phenomenal 116-piece socket set — yes, 116 pieces. If you find a nut this socket set can’t touch, send it to Craftsman and you win a free tour of the factory, Willy Wonka style.

It’s also good to see a pair of extension bars included here for extra torque where necessary, whilst a universal screwdriver with 40 bits and a decent array of Allen keys round out a good collection of quality tools.

Key Features
  • Alloy Steel Construction with Silver Finish
  • 3x Ratchets
  • 116 Piece Socket Set
  • Universal Screwdriver with 40 Piece Set
Specification
  • Brand Craftsman
  • Model 50230
  • Weight 20.3 lbs

Best Mechanic Tool Set Buying Guide & FAQ

It’s a good idea to purchase a high-quality mechanics tool set if you regularly work on your vehicle. We just detailed the best options available, whether you’re expanding your home tool collection, in need of a starter set, or seeking a serious mechanic toolkit that will take care of all your automotive needs.

Below we discuss the top features you should consider before making a purchase and answer some commonly asked questions about tools for your vehicle.

mechanic tool

Things to Look for When Buying Mechanic Tools

When choosing your mechanic tool set, here are some things to consider:

Tool Selection 

Like buying a box of chocolates, you want a decent amount of variety. With our options on this list, you really need to decide how much work you want to be done for you when building your toolkit. If you want everything to come in one box, choose one of the kits that come with varied tools like pliers & spanners. On the other hand, you can choose a set that is more centered on ratchets and sockets, picking up the extra tools as and when you need them.

Tool Box 

Everything needs a home, and car tools need a box. All the kits on this list come in storage boxes, most of them are durable, high quality, and above all else, effective. Some have drawers, some have steel hinges, and some have multiple clasps for added security. Just bear the box in mind whilst making your selection.

Grip 

The grip is a very important — but often underrated — part of a tool. At the end of the day though, it is where the tool connects to your hand, so it needs to be good. Rubber or plastic coated, knurled or diamond pattern etched or even plain, cold steel. Choose the grip that works best for you.

Benefits of Using Mechanic Tools

Why spring for a set of good quality mechanics tools? Well, there are a few reasons we can think off:

  • Time – The right tools for the right job will save you time.
  • Results – Again, the right tools will help you to do a better job.
  • Investment – Automotive tools are not made of butter! Investing in a good set now — or at least the best you can afford — will be laying the foundations of a toolkit that will serve you for years to come.

Mechanic Tools Maintenance

Very simple maintenance will help to keep not just your car tools in good working order, but should really be practiced on all tools. Yes, we know it’s boring, but it’s also essential.

Here’s a guide.

mechanic tool box set

FAQ

Q: What should be included in my mechanic car set?

A: A mechanic tool set is kind of like taking a plate up to a breakfast buffet in that everyone will look for slightly different things. Broadly speaking, a good kit will always include:

  • Ratchets & Sockets – Preferably 3x ratchets, and as many sockets as possible.
  • Universal Screwdriver – Otherwise known as a Magnetic Screwdriver. Basically, looks like a screwdriver handle but with an empty end into which you can slot different bits. Always handy to have around, it’s like 10 tools in 1.
  • Allen Keys – Always useful.

Beyond that, it depends on what extras you need or want. Some suggestions:

  • Extension Bars – You won’t appreciate them until you need them, so they are always good to see in the kit.
  • Spanners – Solid, old-fashioned spanners have been around for about a million years and will always be useful.
  • Pliers – A tool that you will need sooner or later, so it depends if you want to pick them up bundled in a set now, or wait to buy them individually.
  • Hammers – Sometimes it’s just satisfying to hit something with a hammer.

Look, we could write an entire article on the tools that should be found in a well-stocked mechanics toolbox (and maybe one day we will…).

For now, however, check out this great guide here from our pals at Popular Mechanics, who outline the tools that should form the foundation of a well-rounded kit.

Q:  Can I assemble my own mechanic tool set instead of buying one?

A:  Of course, you can! Basically, the positive of buying a ready-made kit as we’ve looked at today is that you are buying the tools in bulk, so you get good value. On the other hand, buying them individually allows for true variety and customization in tool selection.

 So basically it comes down to value vs. customization, and which is the more important to you.

Q:  How should I organize my mechanic tools?

A:  There are as many ways to organize tools as there are grains of sand on a beach, and each mechanic will have their own methods — we don’t have space to list them all here!

Check out this guide here though for a general introduction to some common methods.

Q:  How is quality determined in mechanic tools?

A:  Sadly, there are no set standards when it comes to quality. Instead, what you should do is look for well-renowned companies that have a reputation for making good quality products. Check out some reviews, ask around – and also take a spy at the brands being used at your pro mechanic’s shop next time you drop off the car.

repairing with mechanic tools

Our Top Pick

If you’re looking for a high-quality toolkit that won’t set you back too much financially, we recommend the Crescent CTK170CMP2 Mechanics Tool Set. In addition to its reasonable price, we like this tool set because it comes from a company that’s been in business for over a century. With that kind of history, you know that Crescent has had the time to refine its products so they’re the best they can be.

The tools come in a tough and durable storage case, and they’re easy to take out and put back in. Plus, the SAE and metric tools are good quality and great for those looking for a starter mechanic tool kit. Overall, this product is a good investment and should provide a long service life.

Other Related Reviews

Mechanic Flashlights
Car Creepers
Torque Wrenches
Screw Extractor Sets
Tape Measures
Locking Pliers
Air Impact Wrenches

Sources

  1. Starter Tool List  -Popular Mechanics
  2. How to Organize a Toolbox  -How Stuff Works
  3. Tool Maintenance -Life hacker